Key takeaways
- A University of Copenhagen study published in September 2026 found that bicarbonate, the main source of water’s alkalinity, changed coffee flavor far more than calcium or magnesium.
- At 300 mg/L of bicarbonate, trained tasters rated the coffee much less acidic and fruity, and more bitter and roasted.
- Hardness still matters for your machine: heated together with bicarbonate, calcium forms limescale.
- The best water for espresso machine owners is moderate on both counts: not so hard that it scales, not so alkaline that it flattens flavor.
If you have been looking for the best water for espresso machine use at home, a new study suggests many of us have been watching the wrong number. Researchers at the University of Copenhagen, publishing in September in the Journal of Food Science, found that bicarbonate affects how coffee tastes far more than calcium or magnesium, the minerals we usually mean when we talk about “hard” water.
What the researchers tested
The team, from the university’s chemistry and food science departments, brewed the same Colombian coffee with ultrapure water as a baseline. Then they added calcium, magnesium and bicarbonate, alone and in combination. Levels ran from the low end of the Specialty Coffee Association’s recommended “brewing zone” up to deliberately extreme amounts. Tasters first checked whether they could tell the cups apart at all. A trained panel then scored each brew for acidity, fruitiness, bitterness, roasted notes and other attributes.
Hardness barely moved the needle
Calcium and magnesium on their own produced no marked flavor changes, even when calcium was pushed above the levels typically found in drinking water. According to Barista Magazine’s report on the paper, coffee brewed with 264 mg/L of calcium could not be statistically distinguished from the ultrapure reference on any attribute.
Bicarbonate flattened acidity and fruit
Bicarbonate was a different story. As it rose toward the 300 mg/L test ceiling, panelists rated the coffee less acidic, less fruity and less complex, with more bitter and roasted character. Even 120 mg/L was enough for tasters to notice.
| Water addition | What tasters found | Reported numbers |
|---|---|---|
| Calcium, up to 264 mg/L | No significant difference from ultrapure water | — |
| Magnesium | No marked flavor change | — |
| Bicarbonate, 120 mg/L | A difference tasters could already detect | — |
| Bicarbonate, 300 mg/L | Much less acidity, fruitiness and complexity; more bitter and roasted notes | Acidity 12.0 → 2.9 and fruitiness 10.2 → 2.4 on a 15-cm scale; brew pH 4.88 → 5.53 |
| Calcium + bicarbonate | A milder effect than bicarbonate alone | Calcium carbonate dropped out of the water before brewing |
Numbers as reported by Barista Magazine from the study.
The chemistry is simple: bicarbonate is a buffer. It neutralizes some of the acids that give good coffee its brightness, so the cup tastes duller and heavier.
The last row of the table matters if you have hard water. When calcium and bicarbonate were added together, the researchers traced the smaller effect to calcium carbonate forming and dropping out of the water before brewing, which left less bicarbonate in the cup.
Why this matters for your espresso machine
That same reaction is what scales up espresso machines. Heat water that contains calcium and bicarbonate, and calcium carbonate (limescale) forms on boiler walls, heating elements and valves. Steam boilers get the worst of it: steam leaves the minerals behind, so they concentrate over time. That is one reason heat-exchanger and dual-boiler machines need careful water management. See how the main boiler designs compare.
So the two sides of your water do two different jobs:
| Hardness | Alkalinity | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Calcium and magnesium | Mostly bicarbonate |
| Main concern | Limescale in boilers, heating elements and valves | Flavor: buffers acids and dulls brightness |
| Effect on flavor in this study | Little to none | Clear, and stronger at higher levels |
| How water reports list it | mg/L (ppm) as CaCO3, or grains per gallon | mg/L as CaCO3, sometimes as bicarbonate |
| What lowers it | A water softener or a carbonate-hardness filter | A carbonate-hardness filter; a classic softener does not |
The authors suggest that the narrow hardness ranges in common water guidelines may have more to do with protecting equipment than with flavor. For a home barista, that means watching both numbers, for different reasons.
Tap, filtered, bottled or distilled? Water types compared
Here is how the usual options stack up once you weigh both scale and flavor:
| Water type | Scale risk | Effect on flavor | Our take |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unfiltered tap water | Depends on your area; hard water scales quickly | High alkalinity can mute acidity | Check your local water report before you rely on it |
| Softened water (ion exchange) | Low | Alkalinity stays the same, and sodium goes up | Protects the boiler, but doesn’t fix flat-tasting coffee |
| Filter that reduces carbonate hardness | Lower | Lower alkalinity, brighter cups | A good balance for most homes |
| Bottled spring or mineral water | Varies widely | Varies; some mineral waters are very high in bicarbonate | Read the label for bicarbonate (HCO3) and hardness |
| Distilled or reverse-osmosis water | Very low | Flat on its own | Many machine makers advise against it; check your manual |
| Remineralized water or mineral recipes | You control it | You control it | Keep bicarbonate modest when you mix your own |
A note on labels: filter makers use “limescale reduction” for both softening and carbonate-hardness filters. If you want lower alkalinity, look for “carbonate hardness” or “alkalinity” reduction in the specs, not just “softening.”
Best water for espresso machine owners: what to do at home
- Find your numbers. Community water systems in the US must give customers an annual water quality report, the Consumer Confidence Report, and many list hardness and alkalinity. If yours doesn’t, an inexpensive total-alkalinity test kit will do.
- Convert the units. Reports usually list alkalinity “as CaCO3”. Multiply by about 1.22 to compare it with the bicarbonate figures in this study:
| Your report: alkalinity as CaCO3 | Same water as bicarbonate | How it compares with the study |
|---|---|---|
| 40 mg/L | about 49 mg/L | — |
| 100 mg/L | about 122 mg/L | Close to the 120 mg/L level tasters could detect |
| 250 mg/L | about 305 mg/L | Close to the 300 mg/L level where acidity fell from 12.0 to 2.9 |
- Keep alkalinity modest. The study doesn’t give an exact cutoff, but tasters already noticed 120 mg/L of bicarbonate, roughly 100 mg/L as CaCO3 on a water report.
- Choose the right filter. Pick one that reduces carbonate hardness: it lowers both scale and alkalinity, while a classic softener only deals with scale.
- Don’t go to extremes. Distilled or straight reverse-osmosis water is not the fix. Many espresso machines need some minerals to sense water levels, and very pure water can be aggressive toward metal parts. Follow your machine’s manual.
- Check the water before you blame the beans. If fresh, well-ground coffee still tastes flat, alkalinity is a likely suspect.
- Keep descaling. Even with good water, regular care matters. See our espresso machine maintenance routine.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best water for an espresso machine?
Water that is neither very hard nor very pure, with modest alkalinity. Hardness drives scale, while alkalinity drives flavor. For many homes, tap water run through a filter that reduces carbonate hardness is a practical choice. Always check your machine maker’s water recommendations.
Does hard water make coffee taste bad?
In this study, calcium and magnesium alone barely changed the flavor. The bigger factor was bicarbonate, which often comes along with hard water. Hard water is still bad news for your machine because of limescale.
Can I use distilled water in my espresso machine?
Not on its own. Many machines need some minerals to sense water levels, and very pure water can be aggressive toward metal parts. Follow your manual.
Is bottled water good for espresso?
It can be, but brands vary widely. Check the label for bicarbonate (HCO3) and hardness. Very high bicarbonate can flatten the cup, and high hardness adds scale.
How do I find out my water’s alkalinity?
Look for “alkalinity” or “total alkalinity” in your utility’s annual Consumer Confidence Report, or use a test kit. Most reports list it as mg/L as CaCO3; multiply by about 1.22 to get bicarbonate.
The fine print
The panel tasted a single medium-roast coffee, and the researchers did not measure extraction yield. Lighter roasts may respond differently, and so may espresso, with its short, high-pressure extraction. Still, the direction is clear, and it gives home baristas a practical place to start: measure alkalinity, keep it modest, and let your coffee’s acidity come through.
Sources
- Rune C. J. B., Steen I., Kjærgaard E. R., Maroun Z., Bredie W. L. P., Kjaergaard H. G. “Impact of Water Composition on Coffee Sensory Properties: A Comprehensive Analysis.” Journal of Food Science 91(9), e71434 (2026). doi.org/10.1111/1750-3841.71434
- Barista Magazine. “How Bicarbonate, Not Water Hardness, May Be the Key to Better-Tasting Coffee.” November 10, 2026. baristamagazine.com
- US EPA. “Consumer Confidence Reports (CCR).” epa.gov/ccr

